Evaluation of community-based livelihood development initiatives: The sustainable livelihood approach
View/
Date
2022Page views
1,463ASFA keyword
AGROVOC keyword
Taxonomic term
Geographic names
Metadata
Show full item recordShare
Abstract
The sustainable livelihood approach (SLA) is a tool for evaluating livelihood strategies that utilize assets categorized as environmental, human, physical, financial and social assets. In this study, the SLA was applied to determine the main factors that influence the adoption of integrated multi-trophic aquaculture (IMTA) in milkfish (Chanos chanos Forsskål) farming among fisherfolks. The community-based field trials conducted in Nueva Valencia in Guimaras province for 4 years since 2015 revealed that stakeholders were receptive to IMTA and were able to situate its effects on livelihood assets. The assessment of 52 stakeholders showed small but significant improvements in most livelihood assets during the 3-phased evaluation period. Using the 5-scale Likert rating, the environmental livelihood assets were rated highest but showed slight significant decline due to perceived weather and water level changes that may have negatively affected fish production and income. Financial livelihood assets were initially rated low but significantly improved due to supplemental income derived from wages and harvest. The human livelihood assets significantly improved due to sustained hands-on aquaculture experience. Social livelihood assets also improved due to cohesive interaction during projects implementation. In contrast, the acquisition of physical livelihood assets did not significantly improve because these assets were not commensurate with the many stakeholders who would like to have access to these shared assets. Overall, stakeholders expect IMTA’s potential environmental and economic benefits to overcome additional adoption costs. These include the cost of physical and financial investments in seeds of co-culture species and modified enclosures. Stakeholders expect institutional and government support on further studies on the technical details of IMTA. Fisheries and aquaculture regulations should embed the necessary support systems for the adoption of IMTA and ensure a positive public perception of aquaculture.
Suggested Citation
Salayo, N. D., Castel, R. J. G., Montinola, Q. S., Diamante, R. A., & Kodama, M. (2022). Evaluation of community-based livelihood development initiatives: The sustainable livelihood approach. In A. J. G. Ferrer (Ed.), Proceeding of Joint International Conference of the Sixth International Conference on Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences (ICFAS 6) and Asian Fisheries Social Science Research Network Forum One (AFSSRN F1), 24-26 November 2021, via Zoom, Miagao, Iloilo, Philippines (pp. 473–480). University of the Philippines Visayas.
Type
Conference paperISBN
9786218285125Collections
- Conference Proceedings [300]
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Evaluation of livelihood assets in community-based on-farm demonstration of IMTA in milkfish mariculture in Guimaras, Philippines
(Aquaculture Department, Southeast Asian Fisheries Development Center; Japan International Research Center for Agricultural Sciences, 2022-07)This study showed the need to develop the livelihood assets of rural communities to enable them to engage in aquaculture-based income generating activities. The SLA evaluation showed that the benefits in terms of its contribution to livelihood asset build-up is generally positive. While human, social and environmental capacities were improved, the financial and physical assets were dissipated and insufficient for many stakeholders with keen interest to participate in the communal project. Therefore, the recommendation is to organize more and bigger collaborative projects, such as this IMTA of milkfish, with emphasis on sustainable livelihood asset development to create significant economic impact to target beneficiaries. -
Community-based shrimp stock enhancement for coastal socio-ecological restoration in the Philippines
(Aquaculture Department, Southeast Asian Fisheries Development Center, 2015)The reality of declining quality of coastal areas has been evident for many developing countries, especially in Southeast Asia. In the Philippines, rural coastal zones and estuaries are now being characterized by declining wild fisheries resources and degrading environment. This paper presents, as an example, the typical rural coastal towns of New Washington and Batan in Aklan province, Philippines and showcases how the concept of shrimp stock enhancement can provide incentives to restore the environment and provide sustainable fishing livelihood in the area. The New Washington-Batan Estuary in northeast Panay Island, Philippines was a productive fishing ground that has been in a state of degenerating brackishwater fisheries and estuarine environment. Average daily catch composed of various species decreased from 24 kg in 1970s to 0.7 kg at present. Shrimp fisheries, the most important livelihood, declined in quality and quantity. The highly-priced and once very abundant tiger shrimp Penaeus monodon was replaced with smaller-sized and lower-priced species like the Metapenaeus ensis. These can be attributed to the conversion of 76% of mangroves to culture ponds in the past 50 years and more than 400% increase in fishing gears since the 1990s. The need to reduce fishing structures and rehabilitate mangroves is evident. However, these drastic changes directly affect fishers livelihood. This paper explores the prospects of P. monodon stock enhancement as positive reinforcement for the estuary s rehabilitation. Number of gears per fisher may have to be reduced but shrimp catches will be relatively high-priced. Simulations with additional tiger shrimp caught due to stock enhancement show that fishers can increase income by more than 4 times from their current PhP 34 gear-1 day-1. Campaigns on the importance of mangrove especially as shrimp habitat can encourage local communities to reforest the estuary especially in abandoned ponds. With effective management, law enforcement, and sustained support from different sectors, shrimp stock enhancement can be a positive strategy in estuarine rehabilitation and livelihood sustainability in the New Washington-Batan Estuary. -
Abalone aquaculture for stock enhancement and community livelihood project in northern Palawan, Philippines
(Aquaculture Department, Southeast Asian Fisheries Development Center, 2015)One of the interventions to feed the poorest of the poor fisheries sector in the country is the provision of livelihood in the form of mariculture of high value marine species. In the Philippines, livelihood in rural areas is largely linked to resource depletion, hence it is wise not only to provide livelihood to the community but also to encourage them to conserve and enhance the resources. As part of the revised R&D program, the Western Philippines University partnered with NGO and existing projects to embark on a community-based environment-concerned livelihood project, using hatchery bred abalone, although top shell was also considered for stock enhancement. This is in an on-going project thus, preliminary phases such as abalone production and cage-based grow-out as well as subsequent project plans will be discussed. The objectives of this study were to: (a) share the implementing experiences in this project, (b) identify success and failure drivers of the project, (c) explain the conceptual framework for the MPA-based stock enhancement to be used in this project, and (d) give recommendations to improve the implementation and ensure the success of the project. The following activities have thus far been conducted: (a) development of criteria for cage micro-site selection; (b) writing of proposal and provision of financial assistance for hatchery juvenile production through a partnership MOA; (c) presentation of site survey results to beneficiaries and stake holders; (d) conduct of trainings on abalone grow out culture to POs; (e) development and improvement of training module; (f) signing of conservation agreement; (g) giving of cage materials and juveniles to people s organizations; (h) on site coaching; and (i) partial monitoring. The next activities include improvement in juvenile production, conduct of researches on abalone nutrition, and development of market and value chain flow analysis. The conceptual framework for community-managed stock enhancement will follow that of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources-ICRMP, of which the stock enhancement project is anchored on the management of marine protected areas or MPAs. The steps in all the activities were documented and while the project was in progress, performance of the participants in training were measured, the training module was improved, the training approaches were revised according to needs, and the growth and survival of juvenile abalone were monitored. The problems identified were low production of juveniles, insufficient food for grow-out, political squabbles, social preparation, and delay in implementation schedule. Recommendations to improve or resolve the problems encountered were also presented in this paper.
